1001Philosophers

Karl Lowith Quotes on Time

Karl Löwith’s Meaning in History (1949) gave twentieth-century philosophy of history its most influential analysis of the relationship between Christian eschatology and the modern philosophies of historical progress. The central thesis is that the modern progressive philosophies of history — from Hegel and Marx through Comte and the broader nineteenth-century framework — are secularized versions of the Judeo-Christian theology of providential history, retaining its formal structure of meaningful linear time directed toward a final consummation while emptying it of the theological content from which the structure originally derived. The framework, developed during Löwith’s exile from Nazi Germany in Japan and the United States, shaped Hans Blumenberg’s contrary defense of the legitimacy of the modern age and the broader twentieth-century debate over secularization.

Quotes

  • Attributed to Karl Lowith:

    “Modernity is secularized eschatology.”

  • Attributed to Karl Lowith:

    “Meaning in history is a theological residue.”

  • Attributed to Karl Lowith:

    “The progressive idea of history depends on the Christian idea of providence even when it denies it.”

  • Attributed to Karl Lowith:

    “Without God, history is a meaningless succession of events.”

  • “History, too, is meaningful only by indicating some transcendent purpose beyond the actual facts. ... To venture a statement about the meaning of historical events is possible only when their telos becomes apparent.”

    Meaning in History (1949), p. 5
  • “Peter is the apostle of the Father , Paul of the Son , while John is the apostle of the Spirit who is leading to the full truth of the future.”

    Meaning in History (1949), p. 210

More from Karl Lowith