1001Philosophers

Lao Tzu vs Zhuangzi vs Liezi

Lao Tzu, Zhuangzi, and Liezi are the three foundational figures of philosophical Daoism, with the Daodejing, the Zhuangzi, and the Liezi as the canonical texts of the tradition. The three should be read together as a single Daoist conversation rather than as a strict succession.

Key differences at a glance

Lao TzuZhuangziLiezi
Form Gnomic and aphoristic.Sprawling, narrative, skeptical.Extended fables and dialogues.
Primary concern Sage-rulership and political renewal through wu-wei.Predicaments of the individual sage; relativity of perspectives.Strange and miraculous tales with moral undertones.
Use of paradox In service of a doctrine of minimal rulership.Centerpiece: the butterfly dream; equality of viewpoints.Frame for the suspension of ordinary categorical thinking.
Audience Rulers seeking the way to govern.Sages seeking the way to live.Readers seeking philosophy through story.

Biographical facts

Lao TzuZhuangziLiezi
Dates c. 571 BC – c. 471 BCc. 370 BC – c. 287 BCc. 450 BC – c. 375 BC
Nationality ChineseChineseChinese
Era AncientAncientAncient
Profile Lao Tzu →Zhuangzi →Liezi →

Where they agree

All three held that the dao is prior to all distinctions and cannot be adequately captured in language, all three rejected Confucian ritual and the cultivation of explicit virtue as missing what is essential, and all three held that the sage acts spontaneously rather than from rule or calculation. Each used paradox, parable, and indirection as philosophical methods.

Where they disagree

The Daodejing is gnomic, aphoristic, and closely concerned with sage-rulership and the political renewal a wu-wei ruler might effect. The Zhuangzi is sprawling, narrative, and skeptical, more interested in the predicaments of the individual sage than in political reform, and famously concerned with the relativity of human perspectives. The Liezi develops Daoist themes through extended fables and dialogues, with greater emphasis on the strange and miraculous than the more philosophically austere Lao Tzu and Zhuangzi. Where Lao Tzu addresses rulers, Zhuangzi addresses sages, and Liezi addresses readers seeking philosophical entertainment with serious moral undertones.

Representative quotes

Lao Tzu

  • “The journey of a thousand miles begins with a single step.”

    Tao Te Ching, Chapter 64

  • “Knowing others is intelligence; knowing yourself is true wisdom. Mastering others is strength; mastering yourself is true power.”

    interpreted by Stephen Mitchell (1992) | Variant translation by Lin Yutang : "He who knows others is learned; he who knows himself is wise".

  • “Those who know do not speak. Those who speak do not know.”

    Tao Te Ching, Chapter 56

Zhuangzi

  • “The great bird rises on the wind to a height of a thousand miles. What does it see from on high there in the blue? Is it droves of wild horses galloping? Is it primeval matter whirling in atomic dust? Is it the exhalations that give birth to all things? Is it the blue of the sky itself, or is it only the colour of infinite distance?”

    Ch. 1 (tr. Anthony Watson-Gandy and Terence Gordon, from the French of René Grousset, 1952)

  • “Ch. 1 (tr. Anthony Watson-Gandy and Terence Gordon, from the French of René Grousset, 1952)”

    The great bird rises on the wind to a height of a thousand miles. What does it see from on high there in the blue? Is it droves of wild horses galloping? Is it primeval matter whirling in atomic dust? Is it the exhalations that give birth to all things? Is it the blue of the sky itself, or is it only the colour of infinite distance?

  • “Great wisdom is generous; petty wisdom is contentious. Great speech is impassioned, small speech cantankerous.”

    Ch. 2 (tr. Lin Yutang, 1942)

Liezi

  • “The teachings of the sages can be summed up as virtue and justice.”

    Wikiquote

  • “While sounds are heard, that which made the sounds has not yet begun to resonate.”

    Wikiquote

  • “By knowing and doing nothing, you can know all and do all.”

    Wikiquote

Pairwise comparisons

Continue reading