1001Philosophers

Onora O'Neill Quotes on Virtue

Onora O’Neill’s Constructions of Reason (1989), Towards Justice and Virtue (1996), and the late Bounds of Justice (2000) give contemporary analytic moral philosophy one of its most influential constructivist Kantian alternatives to the dominant utilitarian and Rawlsian frameworks. The central project is the rigorous reconstruction of Kant’s practical philosophy as a constructivist account of moral and political reasoning under the conditions of finite rational agents whose plural perspectives must be reconciled through the actual procedures of public reason — with the corresponding analysis of the imperfect duties of virtue (beneficence, gratitude, the development of one’s natural powers) supplying a substantive account of moral character to which the Kantian framework is often denied. The framework, drawing on Kant and the broader analytic philosophical tradition, shaped contemporary Kantian ethics, the philosophy of trust, and the analysis of practical reasoning across many of O’Neill’s parallel public roles in bioethics and educational policy.

Quotes

  • Attributed to Onora O'Neill:

    “Trust is not a substitute for evidence; it is what makes evidence possible.”

  • Attributed to Onora O'Neill:

    “Universal principles are tested by what they require of all of us, not by what they grant to each.”

  • Attributed to Onora O'Neill:

    “Autonomy is not a feature of separate agents; it is the practice of giving and asking for reasons.”

  • Attributed to Onora O'Neill:

    “Bioethics is moral philosophy in the practical mood.”